In a landmark victory capping a legal saga that has spanned nearly three decades, Telecom Italia (TIM), Italy’s former telecommunications monopoly, has won a final ruling from the country’s Supreme Court entitling it to a reimbursement of approximately €1 billion ($1.2 billion) from the Italian government.
The decision, confirmed by TIM in a statement on Saturday, resolves a contentious dispute over a 1998 concession fee imposed during the liberalization of Italy’s telecom sector, providing a much-needed financial lifeline to the debt-burdened company amid ongoing restructuring. The origins of the case trace back to 1997, when Italy deregulated its telecommunications market, shifting from a monopolistic framework to open competition.
Despite this, TIM—then operating as Telecom Italia and its mobile arm TIM Mobile—was required to pay a license fee of €528.7 million in 1998, comprising €385.9 million for Telecom Italia and €142.8 million for TIM Mobile. The company argued the fee was illegitimate post-deregulation and sued the state for recovery. Lower courts ruled in TIM’s favor, ordering repayment, but the government appealed, prolonging the battle through multiple judicial levels until the Corte di Cassazione, Italy’s highest court, upheld the reimbursement on December 20, 2025.
Register for Tekedia Mini-MBA edition 19 (Feb 9 – May 2, 2026): big discounts for early bird.
Tekedia AI in Business Masterclass opens registrations.
Join Tekedia Capital Syndicate and co-invest in great global startups.
Register for Tekedia AI Lab: From Technical Design to Deployment (next edition begins Jan 24 2026).
The awarded sum is roughly double the original fee, inflated by revaluation and accrued interest over the years. Sources familiar with the matter, as reported by Reuters and Bloomberg, emphasized that the ruling makes the repayment binding, ending what has been described as one of Italy’s most protracted corporate litigations. TIM’s official confirmation aligned with these accounts, though the company has yet to release a detailed press statement on its website.
Financially, the windfall arrives at a critical juncture for TIM, which has grappled with substantial debt and operational challenges in recent years. As of June 30, 2025, the group’s adjusted net financial debt after lease stood at €7.5 billion, stable from prior quarters but reflective of broader pressures in a mature, competitive market. The company reported a net loss of €132 million for the first half of 2025, an improvement from previous periods, with revenues and earnings showing upward trends—bolstered by a positive operational cash flow of €482 million.
TIM halted dividend payments in 2022 to conserve cash amid these strains, but the reimbursement is poised to facilitate their resumption. A key strategic implication of the payout is the acceleration of TIM’s plan to dismantle its dual-class share structure. Savings shares, which guarantee holders a minimum dividend and represent about 28% of the company’s capital, have been a costly legacy feature.
CEO Pietro Labriola, who has spearheaded the company’s turnaround since taking the helm, views the funds as instrumental in phasing out these shares through conversion to ordinary stock. Two sources with knowledge of the matter indicated that the board could discuss this conversion as early as its meeting on December 29, 2025. Analysts suggest this move would simplify TIM’s capital structure, reduce financial burdens, and enhance its appeal to investors.
The ruling’s broader context underscores TIM’s ongoing restructuring efforts. In 2025, the company advanced a major asset sale, divesting a stake in its fixed-line network (Netco) to U.S. private equity firm KKR, a transaction aimed at slashing debt and funding 5G expansions. This deal, part of a wider strategy to streamline operations, has been hailed as a pathway to long-term consolidation in Europe’s telecom sector.
Labriola has publicly welcomed potential M&A activity among rivals, stating in November 2025 that such moves could create a “more balanced and rational” market. Recent analyst upgrades, including from Deutsche Bank in October 2025, have driven TIM’s stock up 6.8% at times, citing evidence of improved free cash flow and sector-wide consolidation prospects.
Market reaction to the court decision has been muted so far, likely due to the ruling falling on a Saturday, with European markets closed over the weekend. Historical precedents offer clues: In January 2025, TIM shares rose modestly by 0.5% after an appeals court rejected a government request to suspend the payment, while a May 2025 delay in proceedings triggered a 5.7% drop.
On the government side, officials have downplayed fiscal fallout. The 2026 budget already earmarks €2.2 billion for national and EU litigation costs, insulating Italy’s push to trim its budget deficit below 3% of GDP. This allocation reflects Rome’s anticipation of adverse rulings in various disputes, ensuring the TIM payout won’t derail broader economic goals.
Given TIM’s financial troubles, the reimbursement that comes with this ruling not only injects vital capital but also signals progress in addressing legacy issues, enabling the company to focus on growth. Analysts expect updates from the December 29 board meeting, which could outline concrete steps toward share conversion and dividend revival.