The laborious process of holiday shopping, traditionally a complex matrix of deciding, price comparing, and review checking, is being fundamentally disrupted by the rise of conversational Artificial Intelligence (AI).
Consumers are now seamlessly integrating generative AI platforms like OpenAI’s ChatGPT, Google’s Gemini, and Perplexity into their buying journeys, treating them as personalized, omniscient shopping assistants. This shift is not merely a trend; it is a seismic commercial event poised to reshape the digital retail landscape and redefine the meaning of online presence.
According to market data published by CNBC, AI has quickly become an indispensable driver of sales and customer engagement this holiday season. Salesforce projects that AI will propel a staggering $263 billion in global online holiday sales, accounting for a significant 21% of all holiday orders globally in 2025. This massive figure is supported by high consumer adoption, with various surveys indicating that between 40% and 83% of consumers are planning to utilize AI tools for their shopping needs this year.
Register for Tekedia Mini-MBA edition 19 (Feb 9 – May 2, 2026): big discounts for early bird.
Tekedia AI in Business Masterclass opens registrations.
Join Tekedia Capital Syndicate and co-invest in great global startups.
Register for Tekedia AI Lab: From Technical Design to Deployment (next edition begins Jan 24 2026).
The value of an AI-fueled customer is proving demonstrably higher for retailers. Data from Adobe shows that shoppers arriving on retail websites via generative AI platforms are 30% more likely to make a purchase and are 14% more engaged—evidenced by spending more time on the site and having a lower immediate bounce rate—compared to those from traditional non-AI sources. Consequently, these AI-driven visits are generating 8% more revenue per session.
This phenomenon is transforming product discovery. For many shoppers, the AI assistant acts as a curator, unearthing relevant brands that might otherwise be overlooked. This is leading to significant shifts in purchasing patterns, as evidenced by one retail tech CEO who reported that approximately half of the gifts she bought came from brands she had never encountered before the AI guided her search.
The new customer journey starts with a conversational query, such as, “Where can I find the best gift under $50 for a tech-savvy teenager who cares about sustainability?” The AI then serves up a tailored, product-level conclusion, rather than a list of generic links.
The New SEO: Pivoting to Answer Engine Optimization (AEO)
The profound shift in customer search behavior is compelling retailers to abandon outdated digital strategies centered around traditional Search Engine Optimization (SEO) in favor of Answer Engine Optimization (AEO). SEO, a game of keyword density and link building designed to rank links on a search results page, is proving ineffective in the age of conversational AI, where the goal is to be the single, definitive answer the AI provides.
AEO focuses on semantics, content structure, and credibility to ensure a brand’s products are chosen by the AI model. Since AI platforms prioritize providing a single, highly relevant, and trustworthy answer, brands are now engaged in a critical restructuring of their content:
- Conversational Structure: Content must be optimized for natural language and provide direct answers to questions in a concise, authoritative format, often using an upfront summary or rich answer blocks.
- Rich Data and Trust: Retailers must provide highly detailed, trustworthy data, including real-time inventory, clear product specifications, brand certifications, and aggregated customer feedback, rather than simply relying on basic attributes.
- Solution-Focused Content: Brands like Ethique Beauty have shifted their content strategy from describing products (e.g., “shampoo bar”) to addressing customer problems (e.g., “solution for oily scalp,” or “how to sleep with curly hair”). This approach aligns with the conversational nature of AI queries, which often begin with a problem or need rather than a specific product name.
Retailers are now directing funds away from traditional paid social media and search campaigns, which are seeing performance declines, and into the infrastructure required for AEO. This strategic pivot, while requiring significant internal and consulting investment, yields a high return on investment because the customer delivered by the AI is typically more qualified and further along the purchasing funnel.
The Retail Giants’ AI Strategy Split and Internal Tools
The country’s biggest retailers are pursuing distinct and competitive strategies to win the AI shopper, primarily defined by their relationship with external large language model (LLM) platforms:
| Retailer | External Strategy (Partnership) | Internal AI Assistant & Features | Key Advantage |
| Walmart | Strategic partnership with OpenAI (ChatGPT), enabling single-item Instant Checkout directly from the chat. | Sparky: Conversational agent on its app for party planning, review summaries, and in-store navigation. | Wide net casting via ChatGPT integration, capturing early-stage advice seekers. |
| Target | Strategic partnership with OpenAI (ChatGPT), offering a multi-item purchasing app within ChatGPT, including groceries and selecting fulfillment (Drive Up/Pickup). | Target Gift Finder: AI-powered tool for higher-engagement, larger cart sizes, trained to understand conversational searches. | Deep functionality and omnichannel experience (groceries, pickup) within the chat interface. |
| Amazon | Exclusionary Stance against external LLMs (blocking crawlers, sending cease-and-desist to Perplexity AI). | Rufus: In-house conversational shopping assistant that provides product comparisons, personalized deals, and can automate purchases based on price alerts. | Control over its vast product data and proprietary AI agents with high automation (agentic AI). |
Amazon’s aggressive approach to blocking external AI crawlers, coupled with its focus on its powerful internal assistant Rufus, signals a strong belief that its massive data moat is a competitive advantage that should not be shared. Conversely, Walmart and Target are betting that placing their products where the customer is starting the conversation—in ChatGPT—will provide superior reach, even if it means sharing the customer experience.
Walmart CEO Doug McMillon has championed this, stating that agentic AI will be a core growth driver, helping people “save time and have more fun shopping.” Target has observed that its Gift Finder tool is already driving higher engagement and larger shopping carts than its previous tools, highlighting the superior performance of conversational, problem-solving AI.
Where AI Falls Short
Despite the momentum, AI shopping tools are not yet universally perfect. Resistance to adoption persists due to functional and psychological barriers, including perceived complexity, risk concerns, and value deficits compared to traditional methods.
When the technology fails to meet conversational expectations, the results can be frustrating. One startup founder, Diana Tan, provided detailed body type, preference, and budget information to a chatbot for a capsule wardrobe recommendation. The tool repeatedly suggested “boring basics” like black shirts and gray pants, leading her to feel like she was talking to a “demented grandmother” and ultimately abandoning the tool.
For consumers who enjoy the process of shopping, the highly efficient, hyper-focused nature of AI can eliminate the serendipitous discovery of browsing. As Tan noted, it “takes the joy out of shopping.”
These instances show that while AI excels at research and optimizing for known intent, it still struggles with tasks requiring deep creative nuance, abstract style sense, or maintaining a human-like, flexible conversation flow. This dichotomy means retailers must continue to maintain a dual strategy, optimizing for both the hyper-efficient AI shopper and the traditional browser, until the AI’s creative and empathetic capabilities mature.