The recent approval of the first Spot Bitcoin exchange-traded funds (ETFs) in the US has been hailed as a major milestone for the crypto industry. Many investors see it as a sign of mainstream acceptance and a gateway to wider adoption.
However, while Bitcoin ETFs are certainly a positive development, they are not the ultimate goal of crypto innovation. In fact, they may even pose some risks and limitations for the future of the decentralized economy.
A Bitcoin ETF is a type of investment fund that tracks the price of Bitcoin and trades on a regulated stock exchange. It allows investors to gain exposure to Bitcoin without having to buy, store, or manage the underlying asset.
Tekedia Mini-MBA edition 14 (June 3 – Sept 2, 2024) begins registrations; get massive discounts with early registration here.
Tekedia AI in Business Masterclass opens registrations here.
Join Tekedia Capital Syndicate and invest in Africa’s finest startups here.
This makes it easier and cheaper for investors to access the crypto market, especially for those who are not familiar with or comfortable with using crypto platforms and wallets.
Bitcoin ETFs also provide more legitimacy and credibility to the crypto industry, as they are subject to the rules and regulations of the securities market. They can attract more institutional and retail investors who may otherwise be wary of the volatility, security, and legality of crypto assets.
Moreover, they can increase the liquidity and price discovery of Bitcoin, as more trading activity and demand will reflect on its market value.
What are the drawbacks and challenges of Bitcoin ETFs?
However, Bitcoin ETFs are not without their drawbacks and challenges. For one thing, they do not give investors any ownership or control over their Bitcoin holdings. Investors only own shares of the ETF, not the actual Bitcoins.
This means that they cannot use their Bitcoins for transactions, lending, staking, or any other use cases that the crypto ecosystem offers. They also cannot benefit from any forks, airdrops, or upgrades that may occur on the Bitcoin network.
Another issue with Bitcoin ETFs is that they may create a disconnect between the price and the supply of Bitcoin. Unlike traditional ETFs that hold physical assets like gold or oil, Bitcoin ETFs do not have to buy or sell Bitcoins to match their fund size.
Instead, they use derivatives contracts such as futures and swaps to track the price of Bitcoin. This means that the demand for Bitcoin ETFs may not translate into actual demand for Bitcoin itself, and vice versa. This could create arbitrage opportunities and distortions in the market.
Furthermore, Bitcoin ETFs may expose investors to additional risks and costs that are not inherent to Bitcoin itself. For example, investors may face counterparty risk if the ETF provider or the derivatives issuer defaults or goes bankrupt.
They may also incur higher fees and taxes than if they directly own Bitcoins. Additionally, they may be subject to regulatory uncertainty and changes that could affect the performance and availability of the ETF.
What is the ultimate goal of crypto innovation?
The ultimate goal of crypto innovation is not to replicate or replace the existing financial system, but to create a new one that is more open, inclusive, transparent, and efficient.
Crypto assets are not just passive instruments for speculation, but active agents for value creation and exchange. They enable users to participate in a global network of peer-to-peer transactions, governance, and innovation, without intermediaries or gatekeepers.
Bitcoin ETFs are a welcome step towards bringing more awareness and adoption to the crypto industry, but they are not the end game. They are a bridge between the old and the new world, but not the destination.
The true potential and value of crypto lies beyond the confines of traditional finance, in the realm of decentralized applications, platforms, and protocols that are powered by crypto assets. That is where the real innovation and transformation will happen.