Home Latest Insights | News India Seeks More Than $150m From Xiaomi in Royalty Dispute That Could Reshape Contract Manufacturing Rules

India Seeks More Than $150m From Xiaomi in Royalty Dispute That Could Reshape Contract Manufacturing Rules

India Seeks More Than $150m From Xiaomi in Royalty Dispute That Could Reshape Contract Manufacturing Rules

India’s government has accused Xiaomi and its former contract manufacturer Flex of failing to fully disclose royalty arrangements linked to smartphone production, as it seeks to recover unpaid import duties and penalties from the Chinese technology company in a dispute that could cost its Indian business more than $150 million.

In court filings, the government said Xiaomi disclosed relevant licensing agreements only after Indian investigators began examining its import arrangements. The allegations form part of a closely watched Supreme Court case that could influence how India assesses transactions between multinational companies and contract manufacturers.

The dispute centers on whether royalty payments made by Xiaomi to technology partners should have been included in the customs value of components imported for manufacturing smartphones in India. Indian authorities argue that excluding those payments resulted in the underpayment of import duties.

Xiaomi maintains that the components were imported by its contract manufacturers and that royalty payments, generally ranging from 2% to 5%, were separate transactions that should not attract additional customs duties.

The company filed a challenge in the Supreme Court in January against an earlier ruling by an Indian tribunal, which found that it had underpaid duties over three years before 2020 by excluding royalties from the declared value of imported phone components.

In a September 21 filing seeking dismissal of Xiaomi’s challenge, the government said the company “knew the licensing arrangements under which it made the royalty payments and failed to make the required complete disclosure.”

The filing added that Xiaomi provided the licensing agreements only after the investigation began. Authorities are relying on that position to support their demand for unpaid taxes and penalties.

Reuters reported the contents of the filing for the first time.

The case has implications beyond Xiaomi because India’s electronics industry relies heavily on contract manufacturing, with global companies using local production partners to assemble devices and manage supply chains.

Companies including Foxconn, Jabil and Tata Electronics have expanded their manufacturing operations in India as the country seeks to attract investment and establish itself as a major alternative production base.

The dispute raises questions about how customs authorities should assess transactions when a brand owner, technology licensors and a contract manufacturer are involved in producing and importing goods.

Xiaomi’s position is that its manufacturing partners import the components and that the separate royalties paid for technology licensing should not be added to their customs value. India’s argument is that the licensing arrangements form part of the underlying commercial structure and should have been disclosed to customs officials when determining the correct value of the imports.

Customs duties are calculated using the declared value of imported goods. If royalty payments are considered part of that value, companies could face additional duties, interest and penalties on components imported over several years.

A ruling in favor of the government could therefore increase the compliance burden for multinational companies whose manufacturing arrangements involve separate payments for intellectual property, technology or production rights.

The government has, however, rejected the suggestion that its case represents a general challenge to contract manufacturing. In its filing, it said the action against Xiaomi “does not proceed upon a proposition that all contract manufacturing is impermissible.”

That position is relevant for India’s efforts to attract manufacturers. The dispute concerns how particular transactions were structured and disclosed, rather than an outright rejection of the contract manufacturing model.

Flex Faces Separate Challenge Over Import Valuation

India’s government is also seeking to dismiss a separate Supreme Court challenge filed by Flextronics Technologies India, the Indian unit of US-listed Flex.

Earlier this year, the company asked the Supreme Court to overturn an Indian tax tribunal’s finding that contract manufacturers had “willingly participated in the layering of transactions”. Flex argued that it had not helped Xiaomi undervalue imports into India.

Flextronics was rebranded globally as Flex in 2015, although its Indian subsidiary continues to operate under the name Flextronics Technologies India.

In a separate filing dated September 11, the government argued that Flex was liable for “failing to place the underlying contractual structure before the customs authorities” to establish the correct import valuation.

The separate challenges indicate that the authorities are examining the responsibilities of both the brand owner and its manufacturing partner. The outcome could help establish how much information contract manufacturers must provide about agreements between their customers and third-party technology licensors.

For manufacturers, the issue extends beyond the payment of royalties. It concerns the possibility of customs authorities looking beyond the immediate importer and examining the wider commercial arrangements behind a shipment when determining its taxable value.

A ruling against Xiaomi and Flex could encourage similar scrutiny in other industries, including pharmaceuticals, automobiles and broader manufacturing, where companies frequently separate intellectual property ownership, production and distribution across different entities.

Experts say such a decision could have implications for businesses operating through complex supplier and licensing arrangements. Companies may need to review whether their customs declarations adequately account for payments made under agreements separate from the physical import of goods.

The case comes as India seeks to attract more global manufacturers and deepen its position in electronics supply chains. Xiaomi holds about 12% of India’s smartphone market, making the dispute commercially significant for a company that has established a substantial presence in the country.

The government is also pursuing other regulatory matters involving the Chinese smartphone maker. India’s Serious Fraud Investigation Office has proposed an investigation into alleged irregularities in Xiaomi’s business model, Reuters reported. Xiaomi has not commented on the proposed probe.

The royalty case adds another layer of regulatory uncertainty for the company, while raising questions about how India intends to enforce customs rules across complex manufacturing networks.

No posts to display

Post Comment

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here