Trade costs in Nigeria and Ethiopia are Five Times Higher than those in the US – World Bank

In a recent publication titled Africa Pulse, the World Bank highlighted the significant disparity in trade costs between Nigeria, Ethiopia, and the United States, attributing it to a multitude of factors including insecurity, transportation costs, topography, and poor road infrastructure.

According to the report, trade costs in Nigeria and Ethiopia are four to five times higher than those in the United States, which has profound implications for market integration and economic development across Africa.

The World Bank noted the detrimental effects of market distortions, which result in price discrepancies for imported food and non-food products, indicating a lack of market integration within African economies.

The report stated, “Similarly, access to product markets is constrained, which prevents firms and farms from scaling up their production. In particular, the lack of connectivity and market integration means that markets are segmented, allowing firms or farms with market power to capture benefits, contributing to income inequality.”

“Studies from the Africa region consistently find spatial differences in prices of imported goods (food and non-food) as well as nontraded agricultural staples, indicating that markets are not well-integrated, and the retail prices of products are affected by distance.

“For instance, trade costs are four to five times higher in Ethiopia and Nigeria than in the United States, due to poor road infrastructure, low competition in the transportation sector, topography,” the report continued.

Moreover, the high trade costs in Nigeria and Ethiopia discourage exports, leading African producers to prioritize local markets over international trade. This preference for domestic sales further perpetuates market segmentation and inhibits the expansion of African businesses on the global stage.

The report further noted, “The consequences of these distortions include the preference of African producers to sell locally rather than export. Furthermore, frictions in the labour markets across Africa are as a result of high transport cost, elevated cost of screening workers and lack of information on labour opportunities.”

In addition to trade costs, the World Bank highlighted frictions in labor markets across Africa, which are exacerbated by high transport costs, elevated screening costs for workers, and a lack of information on labor opportunities. These challenges hinder labor mobility and contribute to unemployment and underemployment in the region.

The report also noted the role of state involvement in creating barriers to trade competition and investment across Africa. Regulatory frameworks often favor big players in the market, allowing them to set prices above market rates to the detriment of consumers, small competitors, and workers.

It stated, “Global analysis of World Bank and Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development indicators of product market regulations suggest that barriers to competition in product markets tend to be higher in African countries, due to a high degree of state involvement in markets, legal and administrative barriers to entrepreneurship, as well as barriers to trade and investment.”

The implications weigh heavily on economic growth

Findings show that the implications of high trade costs, market distortions, and regulatory barriers on economic growth in Nigeria, Ethiopia, and other African countries are multifaceted and profound. These factors have been noted to hinder the development and expansion of industries, limit market integration, stifle innovation, and perpetuate income inequality.

Below are some noted key implications:

Reduced Competitiveness: High trade costs and market distortions make it more expensive for businesses to import and export goods, reducing their competitiveness in the global market. This limits the growth potential of industries and stifles economic diversification efforts.

Limited Market Integration: Market segmentation resulting from trade costs and distortions prevents firms from accessing larger markets and scaling up their production. This lack of market integration limits economies of scale and efficiency gains, constraining overall economic growth.

Income Inequality: Market distortions, particularly those that benefit large players at the expense of smaller competitors, contribute to income inequality. By allowing dominant firms to set prices above market rates, market distortions exacerbate disparities in income distribution, undermining social cohesion and economic stability.

Reduced Investment and Innovation: Regulatory barriers and market distortions discourage investment and innovation by creating uncertainty and limiting opportunities for small businesses and entrepreneurs. This stifles entrepreneurship and inhibits the development of new industries and technologies that could drive economic growth.

Limited Export Potential: High trade costs and market distortions discourage exports, as African producers often prioritize local markets due to the challenges associated with international trade. This limits foreign exchange earnings and reduces opportunities for economic diversification through export-led growth strategies.

Impeded Labor Market Efficiency: Frictions in labor markets resulting from high transport costs and limited information on labor opportunities contribute to unemployment and underemployment. This inefficiency hampers overall productivity and economic growth by restricting labor mobility and hindering the matching of workers with suitable employment opportunities.