Environmental, Social and Governance (ESG) goals are becoming increasingly important for businesses and investors around the world. ESG goals refer to the criteria that measure the sustainability and social impact of an organization’s activities, such as reducing greenhouse gas emissions, promoting diversity and inclusion, and ensuring ethical governance practices.
Bitcoin, the leading cryptocurrency, has often been criticized for its perceived negative impact on some of these goals, especially the environmental one. Bitcoin’s energy consumption and carbon footprint have been widely debated and scrutinized, as the network relies on a proof-of-work (Pow) consensus mechanism that requires a large amount of computing power to secure transactions and generate new coins.
However, a recent report by KPMG, one of the Big Four accounting firms, challenges this narrative and highlights how Bitcoin can actually contribute to ESG goals in various ways. The report, titled “Bitcoin: A catalyst for ESG innovation”, was published in July 2023 and explores the potential benefits of Bitcoin for the environment, society and governance. Some of the key points from the report are:
Tekedia Mini-MBA edition 14 (June 3 – Sept 2, 2024) begins registrations; get massive discounts with early registration here.
Tekedia AI in Business Masterclass opens registrations here.
Join Tekedia Capital Syndicate and invest in Africa’s finest startups here.
Bitcoin can enable renewable energy adoption and innovation. Bitcoin miners, who are incentivized to find the cheapest and most reliable sources of electricity, can act as flexible demand for renewable energy sources that are intermittent and variable, such as solar and wind. By providing a steady and predictable revenue stream for renewable energy producers, Bitcoin can help them overcome some of the challenges they face in competing with fossil fuels. Moreover, Bitcoin can also spur innovation in renewable energy technologies, such as battery storage, microgrids and smart contracts, as miners seek to optimize their operations and reduce costs.
Bitcoin can foster financial inclusion and social empowerment. Bitcoin’s decentralized and permissionless nature allows anyone with an internet connection and a smartphone to access a global and open financial system, without intermediaries or barriers. This can benefit millions of people who are unbanked or underbanked, especially in developing countries where traditional financial services are scarce, expensive or unreliable. Bitcoin can also enable peer-to-peer transactions, remittances, micropayments, crowdfunding and charitable donations, among other use cases, that can empower individuals and communities to improve their economic and social well-being.
Bitcoin can enhance transparency and accountability in governance. Bitcoin’s public and immutable ledger provides a verifiable record of all transactions that take place on the network, which can increase trust and reduce fraud and corruption. Bitcoin can also enable new forms of governance that are more democratic, participatory and inclusive, such as decentralized autonomous organizations (DAOs), which are entities that operate according to predefined rules encoded in smart contracts, without human intervention or hierarchy. DAOs can facilitate collective decision-making, resource allocation and coordination among stakeholders, such as investors, customers, employees and suppliers.
The report concludes that Bitcoin is not only a disruptive technology that challenges the status quo of the existing financial system, but also a catalyst for ESG innovation that can create positive change for the environment, society and governance. The report also acknowledges that Bitcoin still faces some challenges and risks in achieving its full potential, such as regulatory uncertainty, scalability issues, cyberattacks and public perception. However, it argues that these challenges can be overcome with collaboration and innovation from various stakeholders, including policymakers, regulators, industry players, academics and civil society.
Bitcoin Impacts to ESG
Environmental, social and governance (ESG) criteria are increasingly important for investors and consumers who want to align their values with their financial decisions. However, Bitcoin, the most popular cryptocurrency, poses some challenges for ESG performance.
Environmental Impact
The most obvious and controversial impact of Bitcoin is its environmental footprint. Bitcoin relies on a network of computers, called miners, that compete to solve complex mathematical problems and validate transactions. This process consumes a lot of electricity, which in turn generates greenhouse gas emissions. According to the Cambridge Bitcoin Electricity Consumption Index, Bitcoin consumes more electricity than some countries, such as Argentina or Norway. Moreover, most of the mining activity is concentrated in China, where coal is the main source of power generation.
There are some initiatives to reduce the environmental impact of Bitcoin, such as using renewable energy sources, improving the efficiency of mining hardware, or switching to alternative consensus mechanisms that do not require so much computation. However, these solutions are not widely adopted or implemented yet, and the demand for Bitcoin continues to grow.
Social Impact
The social impact of Bitcoin is more nuanced and depends on the perspective of the stakeholders involved. On one hand, Bitcoin can have positive social effects, such as providing financial inclusion, empowerment and innovation for people who lack access to traditional banking systems or face political instability or censorship. Bitcoin can also foster social movements and causes that challenge the status quo or support human rights and democracy.
On the other hand, Bitcoin can also have negative social effects, such as facilitating illicit activities, such as money laundering, terrorism financing or cybercrime. Bitcoin can also exacerbate social inequalities and conflicts, as it is highly volatile, speculative and concentrated in the hands of a few wealthy individuals or entities. Moreover, Bitcoin can pose ethical dilemmas and trade-offs for investors and consumers who have to balance their financial interests with their social values.
Governance Impact
The governance impact of Bitcoin is also complex and controversial. Bitcoin is designed to be decentralized, transparent and democratic, meaning that no central authority controls or regulates it, and that anyone can participate and verify its transactions and rules. This can have positive governance effects, such as enhancing accountability, trust and innovation in the financial system. Bitcoin can also challenge and disrupt the existing power structures and institutions that govern money and finance.
However, Bitcoin also faces some governance challenges and risks, such as lack of oversight, coordination and representation. Bitcoin is vulnerable to technical glitches, security breaches and malicious attacks that can compromise its functionality and integrity. Bitcoin also suffers from scalability issues, meaning that it cannot process a large number of transactions quickly and cheaply. Moreover, Bitcoin is subject to conflicts and disputes among its stakeholders over its vision, direction and governance model. These conflicts can result in forks, splits or changes in the protocol that can affect its performance and value.