For years, the digital news industry has navigated shifting tides, from the decimation of print to the capricious algorithms of social media. Now, a new storm looms, threatening to upend the very foundation of online publishing: the rise of AI-powered chatbots and the precipitous decline of Google search traffic.

WSJ reports that publishers, once reliant on the steady flow of clicks from the search giant, are facing what many are calling an “AI Armageddon,” forcing a radical rethinking of their business models.

Chatbots are increasingly replacing traditional Google searches, providing users with direct answers and eliminating the need to click on those familiar blue links. This shift has begun to starve news sites of the referral traffic they’ve depended on for over a decade.

According to WSJ, the numbers paint a stark picture. For instance, HuffPost has seen its organic search traffic to desktop and mobile websites plummet by more than half in the past three years. The Washington Post has experienced a nearly identical decline in organic search referrals. Business Insider recently cut approximately 21% of its staff, with CEO Barbara Peng citing “extreme traffic drops outside of our control.” Their organic search traffic to websites declined by a staggering 55% between April 2022 and April 2025.

At The New York Times, the share of traffic originating from organic search slid to 36.5% in April 2025, down from almost 44% three years prior. Even The Wall Street Journal, which saw an overall increase in organic search traffic in April compared to three years prior, witnessed its share of overall traffic from search decline to 24% from 29%.

“Google is shifting from being a search engine to an answer engine,” remarked Nicholas Thompson, CEO of The Atlantic, in an interview with The Wall Street Journal. At a company-wide meeting earlier this year, Thompson reportedly urged his team to “assume traffic from Google would drop toward zero.” The Atlantic, he stated, “needed to evolve its business model.”

The introduction of Google’s AI Overviews last year, which summarize search results at the top of the page, has already dented traffic to content like vacation guides, health tips, and product reviews. The recent U.S. rollout of AI Mode, designed to directly compete with chatbots like ChatGPT, is expected to deliver an even more significant blow, as it responds to user queries in a conversational style with significantly fewer links.

“The rapid development of click-free answers in search is a serious threat to journalism that should not be underestimated,” warned William Lewis, publisher and chief executive of The Washington Post, emphasizing the need for the publication to “move with urgency” to connect with overlooked audiences and cultivate new revenue streams in a “post-search era.”

This dramatic power shift underscores the immense influence Google wields in the digital ecosystem, reinforcing long-standing allegations of monopoly. Google’s ability to fundamentally alter how users access information, and consequently how publishers receive traffic, highlights its near-absolute control over a critical gateway to the internet.

While Google executives maintain their commitment to sending traffic to the web and suggest that users who click on links after seeing AI Overviews tend to spend more time on those sites, the reality on the ground for many publishers is grim. Google also states it prioritizes links to news sites and may not show AI Overviews for trending news, but queries for older articles and lifestyle content are more likely to generate an overview.

This isn’t the first technological upheaval for news organizations. The internet itself decimated print publications, and social media, while initially a boon for traffic, eventually pivoted away from prioritizing news. However, many industry leaders believe generative AI represents a fundamental rewiring of internet usage.

“AI was not the thing that was changing everything, but it will be going forward. It’s the last straw,” stated Neil Vogel, CEO of Dotdash Meredith, a media giant encompassing brands like People and Southern Living. Vogel revealed that when Dotdash merged with Meredith in 2021, Google search accounted for roughly 60% of their traffic; today, it’s approximately one-third.

Forced to Adapt

In response to dwindling search referrals and already challenging trends like declining public trust and fierce competition, online news outlets are intensifying their efforts to forge direct connections with readers. This includes a renewed focus on newsletters, improved apps, print magazines, and even live conferences.

The Atlantic, for instance, is prioritizing reader relationships through an enhanced app, more print issues, and increased investment in events, reporting rising subscriptions and advertising revenue. Similarly, leaders at Politico and Business Insider, both owned by Axel Springer, are emphasizing audience engagement.

And There Is A Copyright Battle

Adding another layer of complexity, publishers are also grappling with the protection of their copyrighted material. The large language models powering these new chatbots are trained on vast datasets scraped from the open web, including news articles.

This has led to both legal battles, with some media companies suing AI startups for copyright infringement, and strategic licensing deals. The New York Times has sued OpenAI and Microsoft, while News Corp, the parent company of The Wall Street Journal, has a content deal with OpenAI and a pending lawsuit against Perplexity.

Meanwhile, many observers believe the generative AI race is becoming a significant threat to Google’s own core search business, and this development could spell even more trouble for the tech giant. The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ), citing concerns about Google’s dominance and its impact on competition, has already launched efforts to break up the company. The very actions Google is taking to compete in the AI space, which are simultaneously impacting news publishers, could provide further ammunition for these antitrust cases.

The Apple Safari Effect

However, a glimmer of hope for minimizing Google’s long-standing dominance comes from an unexpected quarter: Apple. An Apple executive recently testified in federal court that Google searches in Safari, the iPhone maker’s browser, had recently fallen for the first time in two decades, despite Google reporting an increase in total searches on Apple devices.

This is particularly significant given the long-standing arrangement where Google pays Apple billions of dollars annually to be the default search engine on Apple devices. If Apple were to reduce its reliance on Google or even develop its own search solution, it could fundamentally alter the competitive landscape and offer a much-needed alternative to Google’s pervasive influence.

The “AI armageddon” for online news publishers is not just a hypothetical threat; it’s a present reality forcing an industry-wide scramble to innovate, adapt, and build direct, indispensable relationships with their audiences in a post-search world.

Microsoft has rolled out two innovative features in beta testing as of June 2025: an AI-powered “enhanced search” for browsing history and a media control center designed to streamline audio and video playback.

These additions, unveiled in early June, aim to address user pain points and elevate Edge’s appeal in a fiercely competitive browser market where Google Chrome, Mozilla Firefox, and even Opera hold commanding leads.

Against this backdrop, many see this as more than a mere feature update—it’s a calculated effort by Microsoft to reverse Edge’s fortunes after years of struggling to gain traction, a challenge rooted in the long shadow cast by its failed predecessor, Internet Explorer.

The Enhanced Features

The enhanced search feature marks a significant leap forward in how users interact with their browsing history. Unveiled in beta versions of Edge last week, it allows users to locate previously visited websites using natural language queries, even if those queries include phrases, synonyms, or typographical errors.

A user searching for a site about “artificial intelligence” might find it by typing “machine learning” or even “artifical inteligance.” This flexibility is powered by an on-device AI model that processes browsing history locally, ensuring that sensitive data never leaves the user’s device or reaches Microsoft’s servers.

Microsoft sidesteps the privacy pitfalls that plagued its controversial Recall feature for Copilot Plus PCs, which captures screenshots of nearly everything a user does to enable searchable content across apps, documents, and websites, by confining data processing to the device. The enhanced search, by contrast, is narrowly focused on browsing history, offering a less invasive approach that aligns with growing user demand for privacy-conscious technology.

The feature’s technical underpinnings are equally compelling. Leveraging natural language processing, the AI interprets queries by recognizing semantic relationships and correcting common misspellings, making it intuitive for users of all technical proficiencies. It’s an opt-in feature, requiring users to enable it manually, a nod to Microsoft’s awareness of privacy concerns following the Recall backlash.

The on-device model is designed to handle large browsing histories efficiently, indexing data locally to deliver rapid responses even on devices with modest processing power. For users, this translates to a seamless experience: no more scrolling through endless history logs or struggling to recall exact URLs. It’s a small but meaningful improvement that could make Edge a more attractive option for those frustrated by the limitations of traditional browser history tools.

Complementing the AI-driven search is Edge’s new media control center, a feature tailored to the growing number of users who rely on browsers for media consumption. Whether streaming music on Spotify, watching videos on YouTube or catching up on podcasts, users can now manage all active media streams from a single, centralized interface.

No longer must they hunt through multiple tabs to pause a video or adjust the volume of a song. The control center also enhances Edge’s picture-in-picture mode, allowing users to watch videos in a floating window while multitasking. This mode, now equipped with intuitive controls for resizing and repositioning, makes it easier to keep a video in view while browsing or working.

The feature supports a wide range of media sources, ensuring compatibility with popular streaming platforms and web-based players. For media-heavy users, it’s a polished addition that streamlines the browsing experience and positions Edge as a viable alternative to competitors.

Edge At The Edge of Competition

These features arrive at a critical juncture for Microsoft, as Edge continues to languish in the shadow of its rivals. Despite its modern architecture and integration with Microsoft’s ecosystem, Edge commands just 4-5% of the global browser market, a far cry from Chrome’s dominant 65% share, and Firefox’s 7-8%, according to recent estimates from web analytics platforms.

The roots of Edge’s struggles trace back to its predecessor, Internet Explorer, a browser that once ruled the internet but ultimately became a cautionary tale of missed opportunities.

Launched in 1995 with Windows 95, Internet Explorer quickly rose to prominence, peaking at over 90% market share in the early 2000s. Its dominance was fueled by its tight integration with Windows, the world’s leading operating system at the time. But success bred complacency. By the mid-2000s, Internet Explorer was plagued by slow performance, frequent crashes, and poor support for emerging web standards like CSS3 and HTML5.

Security vulnerabilities made it a prime target for malware, eroding user trust and frustrating developers who struggled to build modern websites compatible with its quirks.

The arrival of Mozilla Firefox in 2004 and Google Chrome in 2008 marked a turning point. Firefox offered an open-source alternative with robust customization, while Chrome combined blazing speed with Google’s ecosystem, rapidly capturing market share. By the mid-2010s, Internet Explorer’s share had plummeted to below 20%, and its reputation as an outdated relic was cemented.

Microsoft responded in 2015 with Edge, a new browser built from scratch to replace Internet Explorer’s tarnished legacy. In 2020, the company doubled down, transitioning Edge to the Chromium engine—the same open-source platform powering Chrome—to improve performance and compatibility.

However, despite these efforts, Edge has failed to ignite widespread adoption. Microsoft officially retired Internet Explorer in June 2022, redirecting users to Edge, but the stigma of its predecessor seems to linger. Many users still view Microsoft browsers with skepticism, associating them with the sluggish, insecure days of Internet Explorer.

Microsoft’s broader AI strategy provides critical context for Edge’s latest push. The company has made AI a cornerstone of its product portfolio, investing billions to integrate it across its software and services.

While these initiatives underscore Microsoft’s leadership in enterprise AI, Edge operates in a different arena. The browser market is a battleground where user choice is shaped by habit, ecosystem loyalty, and perceptions of performance. Unlike Microsoft 365 or Azure, where Microsoft holds a strong position, Edge faces entrenched competitors with loyal user bases.

Tekedia Mini-MBA welcomes the innovative Africa Prudential Plc team. Africa Prudential is a leading provider of share registration services and capital market solutions, helping businesses manage their shareholder base and streamline operations using digital technology and world class data management systems.

We’re honoured for the opportunity to co-learn with one of Africa’s finest registrars which over 50 years has delivered excellence in the capital market. Welcome and Thank you!