My postulation that entrepreneurial capitalism, not necessarily political efficiency, is the element that would unlock a hopeful Africa, has received many comments in the community. Let me share this one:
Prof., what about the role of governments as an enabler in creating the conducive environment in terms of policies, security, good leadership etc that will inversely give rise and support Entrepreneurial capitalism? Without these enabling environment intentionally created by Governments, Entrepreneurs will seek greener pastures. So my point is, with the mindset in Africa, Governments have got to be intentional, to efficiently provide the enabling environment for Entrepreneurial capitalism to thrive.
Here is the deal, no government policy can work without entrepreneurial pioneers. Any government can make policy but few nations have market pioneers. The broad thinking in Nigeria is that policy must be graded A+ before companies can find value in them. That is untrue. Nigeria has some great business policies on energy, water, education, and banking, with some even better than what is available in the U.S. Look at the last time a Nigerian bank was fined and compare same with what U.S. banks go through with attorney generals in U.S. states. In U.S., a bank is exposed to federal government and all the states where it does business. But in Nigeria, they have mainly the central bank to deal with.
Largely, what new policies do people need to build refineries in Nigeria? What again do we need to build better schools in Nigeria? What do we need to create a software company? I do not know. The excuses of “enabling environment” are pure diversions. Yes, people fail to understand that what are “un-enabled” are existing frictions which need pioneers to fix them. That you lack electricity to run a good school means pioneers that can provide electricity have not risen. That you need good graduates to run your software company but struggle to find them fails to acknowledge lack of entrepreneurial innovators on software education.
At the heart of this is an illusion that Nigerian government has unlimited funds to solve problems because it is government. How can a country with a budget of $24 billion provide good public education, healthcare, security, etc to 200 million people? If you are waiting for enabling environment from that $24 billion, you will run out of time. South Africa spends $122 billion for 57 million people while U.S spends $4.45 trillion on 327 million.
Yet, this is not to say that the Nigerian government has no role to play in helping pioneers to rise. My point is for people to understand how relatively poor we are as a nation. Apple makes on revenue Nigerian budget in 6 weeks. Harvard University’s $5 billion budget is more than 20% of Nigeria’s national budget and more than all that Nigeria spends in all its educational systems, from primary to university levels: 7% of its $24 billion on education – about $1.68 billion.
Simply, one U.S. school spends more money (about 3 times) than all that Nigeria spends on education. U.S. school system is lucky; it has rich companies and people that can make such budgets possible. When Facebook could pay a fine of $5 billion, and not die, you would agree that if Facebook was born Nigerian, more options would be possible for government to expand its playbook. Nigeria does not have Apple, Facebook, etc, and consequently “poor”.
People, Nigeria does not have funds because we do not have companies that would pay big taxes to fund governments. Only when you have such companies would enabling environments make sense. It is the Nigerian government that needs enablement today because it is severely underfunded by the private sectors!
Today, public purses are un-enabled and are practically waiting for private companies to fund them via taxes. But most people do not agree. For most, the only working policy is that one that guarantees good profits irrespective of everything. Unfortunately, it is markets and customers that make such “policies”, not the Nigerian government.
Register for next edition of Tekedia Mini-MBA (June 22 - Oct 22, 2020) here. Four months, online, and costs $140 or N50,000 naira .